LATEST UPDATES
Looks like Honestjoe got it exactly right and he got it exactly right a lot sooner than anyone else admitted to…thanks Honestjoe! Appreciate your reading my blog. From Fox news comes this tidbit.
Several Iraqis have been detained for questioning in the ongoing investigation of at least two senior Iraqi generals suspected of involvement in an insurgent attack that killed five American soldiers on Jan. 20, U.S. officials told FOX News on Thursday.
snipped…further down
The Pentagon has called this a sophisticated and troubling assault and much more orchestrated than the usual attacks on U.S. and Iraqi forces. Because of that, military officials say they have strong suspicions that the Iranian government or elements of it may have been involved. Four of the five American soldiers were abducted before being shot execution style.
Updates on the January 20, 2006 Blackhawk helicopter shootdown with some commentary in response to Honestjoe.
One of the questions regarding that story was the helicopter shot down or did it have a malfunction. While this cannot be said to be proof of a shoot down it certainly bears consideration.
Al-Qaeda claims it shot down US helicopter in Iraq Agence France-Presse Dubai, January 23, 2007
![]()
The Iraqi branch of terror network Al-Qaeda said it shot down a US helicopter that crashed in Iraq at the weekend killing 12 US troops.
In a statement posted on the Internet on Monday, Al-Qaeda in Iraq said its “air defence units” had carried out an ambush at Bhraz in Diyala province around 3:00 pm (1730 IST) on Saturday.
“The lions of the Islamic State in Iraq succeeded in hitting a Black Hawk helicopter,” it said.
“Clashes then broke out with the Crusaders. They resulted in the total destruction of two American Humvee vehicles, with all those on board killed,” said the statement, whose authenticity could not be confirmed.
Source: Al-Qaeda claims it shot down US chopper in Iraq : HindustanTimes.com
Another question was, ok so the helicopter was shot down, lucky shot, so what? The fact that it was shot down is not proof that it was an inside job as Honestjoe declared. And indeed the fact that it was shot down is not proof that there are moles inside of our bases letting our enemies know what we are doing. On the otherhand the United States has some experience with allowing enemies inside the wire. Witness Vietnam where not a single helicopter took off without the NVA and Vietcong knowing where it was going. Furthermore this helicopter was shot down on a day when a lot of other coincidences were occurring.
On January 20, 2006 we had over 25 service men and women killed in action. Of those we had four kidnapped in an operation that had all the earmarks of the Hezb’Allah grab of the Israelis back in December. Some have said that it didn’t make sense for them to kidnap regular soldiers. I believe that those folks are missing the point. It is exactly because those soldiers were regular that they were kidnapped. All the better to use as propaganda. Make some tapes, make some demands, work on our nerves back home. We should be thankful that their suffering ended so quickly as it saved both their families and our nation the spectacle of watching them tortured on tape. As an aside those politicians who think that non-binding resolutions have no affect on our soldiers should be forced to watch the families of those men deal with the loss. Because sure as the sun sets in the west those soldiers were kidnapped because the enemy believes we are close to breaking point and that such a propaganda victory would win the war.
What we saw on January 20 was a push to win the war by an enemy who has proven to be much more adept at the information war than our Government. We have seen some pushback but its come from service members not the government itself. For instance this video takes a cue from the jihadists and shows the US Soldiers winning a fight. (Caution some graphic asskicking going on not for the faint of hear) Before some of y’all go off and say how brutal this is consider that we used to show stuff like this all the time to show the homefront the war is being won. Now we don’t even make fictionalized movies to show the heroism of our protectors in the Army, Navy, Air Force, Marines and Intelligence agencies. But I digress…
While we have no proof that the helicopter was shot down as part of a campaign it certainly seems odd that the insurgents got lucky. They got lucky the same day they got “lucky” and ran a sophisticated special forces operation designed to kidnap soldiers. An operation sophisticated enough to include new GMC Suburban SUV’s, US Uniforms, a blond leader, US weapons and intimate knowledge of their target. Not only that but it was obvious that they had rehearsed the mission. So they got lucky and shot down a helicopter filled with 2 Colonels, 1Lt Colonel, 1 Major, 1 Captain, 2 Command Sgt Majors and several other soldiers…hmmm that is an awful lot of luck in one day of operations.
Now my counterpoint to Honestjoe’s idea’s regarding the big picture.
Right off I want to state up front that I believe that it is entirely possible that Saudi Arabia or major factions within it are at war with us. Matter of fact I believe that to be the case. Indeed it can be also said that major factions within Pakistan are at war with us at present. Furthermore I have a great deal of respect for much of what Honestjoe has posted in the comment section. Finally these are the sorts of debates we should have been having from the beginning in this country.
What I disagree with you, Honestjoe, about is your apparent dismissal of Iran as our enemy as well as your dismissal of Iraq’s threat to the United States. Also though I know that you have stated that you were tired when you wrote these lines mere fatigue does not explain these statements away:
Each day in Iraq helps terrorists and weakens America. We can not fight terrorism effectively while engaging in an act (The invasion occupation of Iraq) that is on par with the behavior of the terrorists and Osama Bin Laden. An exit of Iraq is a first step toward regaining our credibility, strengthening our forces, and being in a position where we can effectively combat the real terrorists.
Further on after apologizing for not being clear because of fatigue you state again that the US is using Terror tactics to carry out the invasion of Iraq. That is just bunk. If anything we have been too soft and pliant in the face of losing US Soldier lives to a variety of actors in the ME…
How can a government that’s been intent upon using the terrorist attacks to carry out the invasion of Iraq, prevent bringing to justice those who’ve been established as being directly responsible for it?
Saudia Arabia as the center of terror
Over and over again we hear how the Wahhabists in general and Saudia Arabia are the center of all evil. I am left puzzled by this belief since prior to the attacks of 9/11 the single worst terror attack suffered by the United States was the Marine Barracks carried out by Hezb’Allah a terrorist outfit sponsored by Iran and not Wahhabist.
Furthermore your idea that Saddam was not linked to and was not collaborating with Al Qaeda and others has simply been proven wrong. My gosh I have to tell you Honestjoe that it is simply inconceivable to me that anyone can miss the evidence showing both Saddams motivations, his means and his methods. They are open source and even a amateur like me can find dozens of pieces that point to Saddam being a threat to this country.
For me though this is not an either or situation. Just because I can point to acts of terror by Hezb’Allah does not mean that I believe our enemies are mainly Shiite. And simply because I understand that Saddam was a Sunni and had plans to attack us does not mean that I believe all Sunnis to be our enemies. The world is much more complicated than that and we have plenty of examples of unlikely alliances against stronger foes.
So it is clear to me that what I have grown to understand these past 5 years is worse than any of us imagined that afternoon on 9/11. We have been under constant attack by Islamic warriors now for over 26 years. They have been both Shiite and Sunni Muslims, funded and trained by a variety of states around the Middle East. We are facing a crisis of enormous proportions in that even in “moderate” states like Indonesia there is a huge amount of support for people like Bin Laden. In 2003 the Muslims of the most populace Islamic nation in the world, Indonesia, were polled by the Pew organization, Bin Laden received a 58% vote of confidence in 2003. Thank goodness it went down to 36% in 2005. We are not being attacked by one or the other Islamic sect we are being attacked by all of them at once.
Does this mean that they, Sunnis and Shiites, are not sworn enemies to each other? Not at all. After we partnered to the Soviets in WW2 we didn’t go for long walks in the rain and exchange spit after the war was over. No indeed not we went directly towards open hostilities. This has been the way of the world since history has been kept. Greeks partnered with the Persians against the stronger Greeks because of animosity between the states. It is sensible that weaker nations will partner with others they may disagree with to defeat stronger nations.
Those who try to say this or that group cannot be collaborating are not saying that because of any actual factual data but because it fits their political view of the world. When you look at the world through the eyes of one who merely wants to keep our country safe it is easy to see the common goals of our enemies…both Sunnis and Shiites.
If you liked my post, feel free to subscribe to my rss feeds
Stumble It!



























BlogoSquare
4 Comments so far (Add 1 more)
5 Trackbacks
texatocudohehacn…
nice post…
[...] thats why so many folks want to avoid confronting the fact that Iran is a Terrorist state using terrorists to further its own aims. Lieberman thank goodness is not one of those folks. Technorati tags: iran, [...]
[...] Courtesy of Pierre Legrand’s Pink Flamingo Bar: [...]
[...] UPDATED NEW POST EXPLAINING SOME ISSUES [...]
[...] Courtesy of Pierre LaGrand’s Pink Flamingo Bar: [...]